Rural-Urban Migration and Agricultural Transformation in India: Observing the Impact on Childhood Migration From Bihar to New Delhi

By Daniel A. Rosenblum
2013, Vol. 5 No. 10 | pg. 3/4 |

In Sitamarhi district, a sugarcane processing plant dominated the land, contributing to the monoculturization17 of sugarcane in the surrounding villages. Farmers would dedicate large portions of their fields to this labor intensive crop due to the demand from the factory. This industrial development was part of the beginnings of during the 1990s. The policy opened up the country to new development projects, allowing private foreign and domestic companies to start production in many of these former agricultural lands. However, unlike the states of Jharkhand and Orissa, which benefited from their rich deposits of lumber and coal18, Bihar was largely left alone from industrial development. The state was known for its fertile agricultural land, rather than its , meaning industrial development was not a primary interest for the Indian government. This left Bihari citizens with crucial decisions to make. If there are no opportunities to work on the land, no impetus by the government to aid in an egalitarian development model, then an uneven model will emerge. People will be forced to migrate to these pockets of development in Jharkhand and Orissa, leaving their homeland behind. This uneven model is unsustainable and highly damaging. As Indu Prakash states:

The entire development paradigm, the way it unfolds in the country, I think it’s been faulted for the people themselves, because people will go where their work is. If you just want to reverse it, you start having some of these things in the rural sector, if the rural sector becomes economically viable, you know, why would you go back?

For rural Biharis who lack opportunities on their land or on the fields of large landowners, it may be more feasible to go out and find a more consistent job. For the youth in Bihar, there is a compulsion to follow this paradigm. Working in the fields is not only unviable, but it is unattractive as a job. Many teenagers expressed to me how they would prefer to have a job working in the city, rather than being a farmer. A discussion with many young men in Amritpur revealed that the majority of them go to work in the district towns or in major urban centers because that is where they felt jobs were. They were only home to farm for a few weeks, then they would return to their urban jobs. They saw no future or possible channels of development in Amritpur, and felt farming was not a fulfilling profession anymore. They had to go to where development existed to find work.19

With privatization and neoliberalism increasingly becoming a part of the Indian economy, the spread of uneven development is on the rise (Anand Kumar, 2008; Pandit, 2012). Pockets of investment are taking precedent over undeveloped regions, many of which are in Bihar, meaning jobs are being shifted out to certain concentrated development regions. An area failing to receive investment is not able to hold onto its inhabitants, meaning a migration to development pockets is inevitable (Deshingkar, 2006; Henderson, 2010). Along these channels men and children will head, searching for opportunities beyond a depressed agricultural system. At the same time, India’s development policy has reshaped how agri is viewed. Under the newly liberalized economic policy, has become integrated into a structure that relies on policies of investment, incentives, and innovations. This system will no longer allow the agricultural sector to strive for self-sufficiency. It is now connected to a larger world economy and without crucial investment in these Bihari agricultural zones, it reaffirms the impossibility of working and living solely on one plot of land. Adults and youth must make pivotal decisions to head to where development is being promoted and incentivized—the zones where jobs and consistent opportunities exist.

Sugarcane fields in Amritpur village, Sitamarhi District

Sugarcane Fields

Beyond Agricultural Migration

While agriculture has played a crucial role in the transformations within Bihar during the last fifty years, it would be unwise to say this is the only factor contributing to a higher frequency of youth migrations. Rather, it is vital that these agricultural transformations that weave issues of landholding, mechanization, climatic changes, and development be understood as intertwining processes which interact with other socioeconomic, historical, and religious dynamics. By examining the dense linkages that tie other critical issues with agriculture, one can begin to see the extreme complexities of youth migration. In this section, I will discuss three significant topics that were reoccurring issues in my fieldwork: rural failures, the caste system, and the perception of rural versus urban lifestyles.

I. Rural Education Failures

For the Bihar government and Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, there has been a constant pressure to improve rural education. Kumar has actually drawn praise from many critics for his first term, where he provided much need infrastructural improvements for the Bihari youth (Ghosh, 2012). In Sitamarhi district, many rural villagers expressed how the educational system has improved significantly in the last decade. The grandfather of a Bhumihar20 family in Baksampur, an upper caste landowner, informed us that “boys are all going to school now. Earlier they use to rear sheep, buffaloes, etc. but now they are getting books, clothes, cycles for free so they have started taking interest in going to school.”21 These improvements have been significant, as they have encouraged more children than in the past to attend school. Yet, the quality of education still varies greatly, meaning many children become de-motivated or uninterested in their studies, and consider leaving school altogether. A large portion of students still drop out even before they turn fourteen, the age of guaranteed education under India’s Right to Education Act (Parliament, 2012). In addition, as I mentioned earlier, the schools I visited, with the exception of one, tended to be chaotic, understaffed, and unsurprisingly lacking much structure. Teachers were rarely teaching, students lacked appropriate books and materials, and the buildings were typically unsuitable as educational facilities. Many students failed to stay the entire day, while others came in late after helping their parents at home or in the fields. This is quite similar to Sainath’s description of Bihar schools some thirty years earlier in Everybody Loves a Good Drought, where many schools lacked appropriate facilities, qualified teachers, and attendance was very inconsistent (Sainath, 1996b). The rural education system in Bihar, despite making strides under Chief Minister Kumar, have failed to reach the standards in urban centers of Delhi and Mumbai, where primary education tends to be significantly better. As a result, many children and their parents fail to see the value of an education versus that of obtaining a job in Bihar. They will, instead, work to provide for the family or go to the cities to find better opportunities. The lack of a supporting educational structure sets the foundation (or lack thereof) for an unstable rural livelihood, pushing children towards the cities in search of better opportunities.

II. Issues of Caste

In rural Bihar, issues of caste are still very prevalent, producing systems that limit access for many marginalized groups. Historically, the zamindari system has left many lower caste families with little to no land, even after abolition in 1948. This has made many lower caste families dependent on higher caste landowners for work, food, and ultimately their livelihoods. In addition, they still must face the intense discrimination of being lower caste. Hoja, the Chamar caste girl who was our guide in Baksampur, faced direct discrimination from the Bhumihar family I interviewed. Hoja was forced to stand at the periphery of the conversation, exposed to the sun outside the cover of the porch. Feet away, sitting comfortably, members of the Bhumihar family discussed the practices of untouchability they continue to follow:

Mother: even we practice it, if someone is a Chamar- belonging to lower caste, they cannot sit everywhere; they have to sit in a particular place made for them
Khushboo: still?
Mother: yes still! He is not allowed to touch anything.
Father: he is not allowed to walk in the village with slippers on.
Mother: I got lime, water myself, have not let my body touch her and have given lime water to you all. We don’t eat anything that is touched by a chamar.
Khushboo: still?
Mother: yes still!
Khushboo: but now everything has changed, it is not like that.
Mother: in village it is a lot. If we have boiled rice and someone from the lower castes touches it, we won’t eat that rice, we will keep it outside.
Khushboo: but when we appoint them as labors in fields and plough fields and do cutting of dhaan, why can’t we eat the same rice?
Mother: we take dhaan from them and boil it to make it rice. We don’t take rice from them. We don’t let them touch our water. When they have some feast we don’t go to eat at their place. Our neighbor’s mother had passed away—for 4 days everyone ate there but no one goes to eat at lower caste people’s house.22

This conversation, while effective in capturing some examples of caste discrimination in Baksampur, fails to reveal the full extent of persecution and marginalization of lower caste people in Bihar. For lower caste adults who try to escape persecution in their village by attempting to start a business in a district town, they still face discrimination. Many times higher caste individuals from their village will come into town and reveal the shop owner’s status to the public, essentially ruining any future business. At some schools, lower caste children are forced to sit on the floor, while upper caste youth are given chairs. Additionally, teachers will give upper caste children preferential treatment, despite stipulations against these actions in India’s education acts. This treatment is very significant when discussing youth migration to urban centers. In Delhi, while casteism still does exist, and can be observed across socioeconomic lines, it is practiced much less. Caste is less of an issue in the city of migrants, where many children can hide their status. On the railways, at temples, schools, and in homeless shelters, caste is less significant, allowing for a greater chance of social mobility and escape from caste-based marginalization. Children have more access and azadi (freedom) in the city, and are not defined by caste the way they are in rural regions of Bihar.

Suggested Reading from Inquiries Journal

The existence of street children is most often viewed as a significant problem, stripping youth of their humanity and burdening them with the everyday concern of survival. It is easy to analyze this complicated issue objectively, yet the actual experiences of the children are just as easily lost. It is therefore necessary to approach the subject with the inclusion of contextual information regarding the problem. Statistical evidence provides only... MORE»
Advertisement
The attacks of September 11th have frequently been characterized as unimaginable, capable of inflicting confusion and emotional trauma beyond the scope of other historical events. On September 12th, 2001, N.R. Kleinfeld of the New York Times asserted plainly that the people of New York had “witnessed the inexpressible, the incomprehensible, the unthinkable.”[1] Moreover, 9/11 has frequently been represented as a point of... MORE»
This paper presents and evaluates the varying roadblocks that make identifying and assessing emotional abuse to children so complex. This is the case for three primary reasons: the lack of a common definition of what constitutes... MORE»
For today's children, technological devices such as iPads, smartphones, and e-readers are quickly replacing more traditional "toys" as sources of learning and entertainment. With their capacity to contain a multitude of activities within a single device, tech devices are the new norm and are being utilized from a young age. Many... MORE»
Submit to Inquiries Journal, Get a Decision in 10-Days

Inquiries Journal provides undergraduate and graduate students around the world a platform for the wide dissemination of academic work over a range of core disciplines.

Representing the work of students from hundreds of institutions around the globe, Inquiries Journal's large database of academic articles is completely free. Learn more | Blog | Submit

Follow SP

Latest in Anthropology

2017, Vol. 9 No. 10
“As Roman imperialism laid the foundations of the modern civilization, and led the wild barbarians of these islands along the path of progress, so in Africa today we are repaying the debt, and bringing to the dark places of the earth, the... Read Article »
2015, Vol. 6 No. 1
Published by Clocks and Clouds
In Jordan, a state renowned for medical tourism, all physicians are proficient in English because medical classes are taught in English, indicating that English, rather than Jordan's official language of Arabic, is the prestige language of Jordanian... Read Article »
2016, Vol. 8 No. 12
The sheer number of distinct dialects present within the country has long complicated Chinese language standardization and language policy. Furthermore, China’s history with colonial powers throughout the past three centuries has led to a... Read Article »
2016, Vol. 8 No. 03
Sporting mega-events in Rio de Janeiro, including the 2014 World Cup and the upcoming 2016 Olympics, employ particular tactics of spatio-temporal scale-making to produce a utopic atmosphere of global camaraderie, modern urban development, and sporting... Read Article »
2015, Vol. 7 No. 11
The traditional mourning and burial rituals common in West Africa played a key role in the recent Ebola epidemic focused in Liberia, Sierra Leone and Guinea. One issue that arose during the height of the outbreak was misunderstanding of burial practices... Read Article »
2010, Vol. 3 No. 2
The word kuchi conjures up a romantic but ultimately anachronistic lifestyle—tattooed women in red and gold embroidered dresses and men riding alongside flocks of goat and sheep; the reality, however, differs starkly. The past two decades... Read Article »
2015, Vol. 7 No. 08
“Not all silences are equal,” writes Michel-Rolph Trouillot (1997, p.27). Not everyone, I add, possesses the power to silence a person or a group of people. In this research paper, I use gender as an analytical tool to examine the way... Read Article »

What are you looking for?

FROM OUR BLOG

Writing a Graduate School Personal Statement
How to Select a Graduate Research Advisor
Finding Balance in Graduate School